There are a myriad of ways to roast a chicken and even more opinions on the best way. You can dry brine, wet brine, spatchcock, rub butter under the skin, stuff with herbs and lemon, bake low and then high, bake high for the entire cooking time…you get the idea. This is why it felt fitting to start off my Cookbook Year adventure with a roast chicken. For me, it represents why I love cooking so much. While there are foundational skills, there is also room for creativity and ways to both honor the recipe developer and make it your own. With that, let’s get into it!

Buttermilk-Marinated Roast Chicken (Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat)

Samin’s buttermilk chicken turned out great. The skin was super crispy, but the marinade did something more than that. The chicken came out tangier and seasoned all the way through, which is different from just salting ahead of time. It was just more… unctuous.

I spatchcocked it instead of roasting it whole, because I think that’s the easiest way to cook a whole chicken, and it worked out really well.

Then I went a little off book. Or rather, I went to a different book. I’m pretty sure Sohla mentions cooking potatoes with the chicken somewhere in Start Here, so I combined the two: parboiled Yukon Golds (medium dice) and roasted in the pan in all those schmaltzy juices. They came out fluffy in the center and very flavorful, but not as crispy as I’d wanted. Next time I’ll roast them separately in some saved schmaltz from a previous chicken, so they get real crunch.

To complement the richness of the chicken, I dove back into Salt, Fat, Acid, Heat for an arugula salad with a bright, lemony anchovy dressing. It was perfect!

The hubby’s verdict: he was very impressed with the difference in flavor (as was I), and of course, everyone loves crispy skin.

Roast Chicken Remix (Bonus)

With the leftover chicken breast (the carcass went into my stock bag in the freezer), I made a Hungry Ginger Original with my sous chef. I’m not a huge fan of chicken breast (it dries out if you so much as look at it). This chicken breast, however, was quite succulent – thanks, Samin! Still, leftover chicken is happiest as the costar, not the star. Enter Cheesy Salsa Verde Chicken & Bean Bake. I had some extra salsa verde kicking around, so I simmered it down with a couple packets of Frontera enchilada sauce and stirred in cream cheese until it went all silky. Layer that with corn tortillas, chicken, beans, spinach and a frankly irresponsible amount of cheese… you see where this is going. It was delish: a little spicy, tangy and cheesy… basically all the good things. Recipe below, friends!

Cheesy Salsa Verde Chicken & Bean Bake

Uses leftover roast chicken breast (or you can buy a rotisserie chicken) and store-bought salsa verde and/or enchilada sauce. One 12″ oven-safe skillet; ~40 min.

Ingredients

  • ~3 cups shredded roast chicken breast
  • 2½ cups salsa verde and/or enchilada sauce
  • 1 can black or pinto beans, drained
  • 2 big handfuls spinach, chopped
  • 4 oz cream cheese
  • 1 tsp cumin
  • 10–12 corn tortillas
  • 2 cups shredded Monterey Jack or Oaxaca cheese
  • 1 lime
  • To serve: cilantro, pickled onions or radishes, avocado, crema, red salsa

Instructions

  1. Heat oven and char tortillas. Heat oven to 400°F. Warm tortillas over a gas flame or in the dry skillet until spotty and pliable — toasting keeps them from going mushy.
  2. Reduce the salsa. Simmer salsa with cumin in the skillet 5–7 min until noticeably thicker and not watery. Off heat, whisk in cream cheese until smooth; add a squeeze of lime. Transfer to a bowl.
  3. Make the filling. Toss chicken, beans, and spinach with about half the sauce. Season with salt.
  4. Layer. Thin layer of sauce in the skillet → overlapping tortillas → half the filling → ⅓ of the cheese. Repeat once. Finish with tortillas, remaining sauce, remaining cheese.
  5. Bake. Covered with foil 15 min, then uncovered 10–15 min until bubbling and browned. Broil 1–2 min for extra color if you like.
  6. Rest and top. Rest 5 min so it slices cleanly. Top with cilantro, pickled onions or radishes, avocado, crema, and red salsa at the table.

Tips

  • Make ahead: Assemble the night before and refrigerate; add ~10 min to the covered bake.
  • Hatch chiles: A few chopped frozen Hatch chiles in the filling are great with tomatillo.
  • Salsa timing: Using fresh salsa but can’t bake for a few days? Do step 2 (without the cream cheese) now and refrigerate — cooked salsa keeps several days longer than fresh.
  • Swaps: White beans for black; chard for spinach.
  • Why it works: Leftover breast is lean and dries out easily; tossing it in the creamy sauce before baking keeps it moist.

Cannellini Beany Melt (Start Here)

The second recipe was from Sohla’s Start Here, made on a night when I was on my own. The beans were really flavorful. I added some extra spices, a little more pickle juice than it called for (shocker), and some garlic salt.

I didn’t have scallions, and I wasn’t about to go to the store just for scallions, so I subbed onion powder and garlic powder. Not the same thing, I know. The celery added a nice crunch, though.

I used American cheese, one of the two options, but it didn’t get as gooey as I’d hoped. The other option was Muenster, which I think would have been better.

Would I make it again? Definitely. Next time it’s Muenster and real scallions. But honestly, the beans were good enough to eat on their own.

The verdict on Week 1

It was a really good place to start: simple and foundational. The beany melt is more of a lunch thing, but really, anything can be dinner, and it was perfect for a solo dinner night.

It felt good to be intentionally using my cookbooks, and I found myself perusing other recipes in those cookbooks and marking recipes with sticky notes that I wanted to come back to. It also felt great to not be staring at a screen. Having a real cookbook, propped up on my little cookbook stand, getting some splatter on the pages, is so satisfying. Next week, we visit England and Italy!

Leave a Reply